Motorola DROID or HTC DROID Incredible?

Neither, you should switch to AT&T and get the iPhone 4. You'll be happy you did. =)

Okay, so I am going to buck the trend here. I LOVE MY MOTO DROID! I was able to install the ADW Launcher (and HTC interface look-alike) and now I have a Droid with the qwerty keyboard that works like the HTC. Plus, my intel has been that the HTCs haven't been that rugged and my DROID has been dropped multiple times with no problems to date.

I have a TON of APPs installed and there seem to be no end in site. I would challenge the 12 hour battery life unless you just aren't using the phone at all...LOL. However, some of the cool accessories like the car stand (which makes it a cool GPS+) and the nightstand charger (which make it a cool nightclock) make great rapid chargers that greatly extend battery life during the day. Strategically placing these in your car/home/office can make battery life virtually a non-issue. It has for me...

If you want to see a discussion on the cool apps, see http://lockergnome.net/questions/18041/what-is-your-favorite-android-app-why#18052

Droid Incredible. Looks quite nice and also a newer device. I've heard good things about HTC android products and their apparent polish

Durability: I have to say the Motorola DROID. But there both really good in this field.

Screen Responsiveness: Definitely the HTC Droid Incredible.

Battery Life: Tie. They both have about the same battery life (around 12 hours.)

Overall I would go with the HTC Droid. I feel it is a very solid phone overall and definitely shows what the Android OS is capable of.

HTC all the way motorola sucks I am on my 5th motorola phone I'm so glad I bought insurance

If you want a sleek, light phone go with the incredible. If you absolutely HAVE to have a QWERTY keyboard go with the Moto Droid.

I really like the droid incredible if you don't want a slide out qwerty. It looks a bit beautiful as well :)

At this point in time, the Droid is transitioning from the high-end to mid-end. It's old, and showing it's age. Honestly, the only reason I am keeping my G1 right now is for the hardware keyboard, and if that's a must, stick with the Droid. But ultimately, the Droid Incredible will beat it out in every other area. Also, if you want to be certain you will receive Android 2.2, get the Incredible. The latest HTC devices always get the advantage when it comes to new Android releases, whereas with Motorola you will be waiting awhile.

That is not a fair battle. Obviously, the HTC Droid Incredible has higher specs. It is better, The Droid is almost a year old. Come on people! Stop comparing new hardware with old hardware!

Wait for the new Droid X that is coming out. http://phones.verizonwireless.com/droid/x/