|
Being behind the scenes has its advantages. :) I've been in his office all morning and all day, and I have had to hear a snootful about the complaints and nasty emails Chris has received from Android fanboys about his latest impressions on an Android product. Trying out the product for myself, I concur: there are "issues". Chris is asked to review products all the time. But one that he wasn't asked to review (among many) or paid to review with any free product are the Apple products, such as the iMac, Mac Mini, iPad, or iPhone. He doesn't receive money, and he's even posted his receipts on the internet so that people can see he had to buy his own product. So it's obvious to me, as a n00b, that he likes Apple products because they perform the functions he wants, with usability features that make sense to him. My question: do you believe fan boys of Android really want to know what Chris thinks of Android products? Do they want truth, or something else? What, if anything, do you believe Android fans want to hear? Would a satisfactory review be able to include pointers for improvement (which, BTW, Chris gives to Apple as well when he finds something that doesn't work well)? |
|
Chris should so what he wants, if he wants to do the reviews he should give his honest opinion about that he likes. It is all about opinion and he should do what he thinks is best. |
|
Some people there is no satisfying what ever platform one favors is there personal preference be apple Linux or even windows. I don't know it's almost like religious fanaticism. I use apple handhelds ubuntu workstations and widows for gaming... i would hope i'm objective in my assessment of were i put my money. I do think Chris is objective and favors apple just as i favor ubuntu. If people cant respect that then well thats there problem the internet is full of ass holes. I disagree with Chris on a few things but not to the point were i go ape shit because after all it's just opinion. Chris dose a great job at what he dose, i hope he keeps it up i wouldn't ignore them, (fanboys) however were they could remind me of how crazy people can get lol. |
|
well..some people like the android better than iOS. he should just let people say what they like and not worry about it. Even fanboys have the right to opinions. |
|
Fanboys are annoying, but let's be fair: Apple fanboys can be just as bad. I don't mean to be dismissive of the issue, it's just that fanboys are a part of reviewing tech products. As for how Chris should deal with them, I agree with Craighton that Chris should give his honest opinions. I'm an Android fan, and I have nothing against people pointing out its flaws. That said, I think Chris would benefit from keeping things in perspective. I said in response to another question that his complaints were all legitimate, it's how he delivered them that was the problem. Getting so outraged over the lock screen that his hands are shaking on cam... that's just not reasonable. So, in short, Chris should not hold back his criticisms but be more humble when making them. His emotional response should be more appropriate for the criticism he is making: taking 10 seconds to figure out the unlock screen once (and never again) is not worth getting so worked up over. Guess I don't have to post my own opinion, this one pretty much covers it. :) Part of Chris' appeal is his lack of humility at times when he's sure of something he sees -- he makes not apologies. At least he's clear about what he's saying. If he makes a mistake, he's just as clear to go back and restate something. "Fanboys are a part of reviewing tech products." I just wrote a blogpost about this, which is currently sitting in Chris' inbox and I hope that you all will have a chance to read it. It talks about the phenomenon of fanboyism, and a theory as to why some people would spend so much time defending their position about about an object. Interesting post (http://bit.ly/cIHiHI), but I think you're reading a bit too much into it. After spending hundreds of dollars on a product (Android, Apple, whatever), some people just can't handle the idea that their purchase wasn't perfect. Others who are more secure in their decisions accept that nothing is without flaws, including the device they purchased. |